Gutter Replacement or Repair: How to Know Which You Need

When your gutters start causing problems, it can be hard to know whether to repair them or invest in a full replacement. As specialists in gutter repairs across Ireland, we often help homeowners make the right choice based on the extent of the issue and the age of their guttering system.
Signs Your Gutters May Need Attention.
- Water overflowing during rain
- Sagging sections or broken brackets
- Cracks, holes, or rust spots
- Stains on walls beneath the gutter line
- Vegetation or moss growing inside the gutter
When Repairs Are Enough.
Localised damage like a cracked joint, loose bracket, or small blockage can usually be fixed quickly. If the guttering is relatively new and the rest is in good condition, repairs are the cost-effective choice.
When Replacement Is the Best Option.
- Gutters over 20 years old
- Widespread rust or brittleness (for metal systems)
- Plastic gutters with repeated splits or warping
- Ongoing leaks despite previous repairs
- Poor installation or incorrect fall angle
Professional Advice Makes the Difference.
Patrick Hannifin Roofing provides honest, practical advice based on what’s best for your property. We can inspect your current guttering and advise whether a repair or replacement is more suitable.
We also offer fascia and soffit repairs alongside guttering, ensuring your full roofline system is secure and functioning as it should.
Can I replace just a section of guttering?
Yes, but only if the rest is still in good shape and compatible with the new section.
What’s the best gutter material in Ireland?
uPVC is popular for being durable and low-maintenance. Aluminium is another strong, rust-resistant choice.
How long does a guttering system last?
uPVC gutters usually last 20–30 years. Metal systems can last even longer with proper care.
Are leaking gutters dangerous?
Yes. They can lead to damp walls, foundation issues, and internal water damage if left unchecked.


